Speech delay or autism? How to tell the difference
Speech Clinic Speech Clinic 7 min read
The difference between a speech delay and autism is usually seen in how a child communicates without words. A child with a speech or language delay alone is late to talk but still points, gestures, looks to you and plays in the expected ways. An autistic child may also be late to talk, but the differences reach further, into gestures, shared attention, play and how they respond to people.
Most toddlers who are late to talk are not autistic. No article can tell you which applies to your child, and the two can overlap. What this one can do is show you what professionals look at and who to see.
What is a speech delay?
A speech or language delay means a child is developing talking or understanding in the usual order but later than expected. Toddlers with a delay in talking and no other concerns are often called late talkers. Late talking affects around 10 to 20 per cent of two-year-olds.
As a guide, most children say their first words at around 12 months, and by about two years they use around 50 words and start joining two words together. A child who is not using about 50 words or combining words by two is worth having checked.
Many late talkers catch up. Studies that follow them over time find that most score in the average range for language by the early school years, although as a group they tend to stay a little behind children who talked on time. Some go on to have a lasting language difficulty, and it is hard to predict which children will catch up without help. That is the reason not to wait and see. For more, read My 2 year old is not talking: when to worry.
What is autism?
Autism is a neurodevelopmental difference that affects how a person communicates, interacts and experiences the world. It is not a speech problem, and it often runs in families. Some autistic children talk late and some do not.
The Royal Children’s Hospital Melbourne describes signs of autism in young children across several areas. In communication and social interaction, a child may take longer to talk, use few gestures, make less eye contact or prefer to play alone. The other areas are repetitive movements or speech, a strong need for routine, intense interests, and strong reactions to sounds, textures or light. Not every child with these signs is autistic, and every autistic child is different.
Speech delay vs autism: what is the difference?
The main difference between a speech delay and autism is whether the difficulty is limited to talking. One study compared toddlers with a language delay to autistic toddlers with the same amount of speech. The children with a language delay were much closer to typically developing children in three things: using gestures to communicate, pretend play, and responding to language.
| What to watch | More typical of a speech or language delay alone | More often seen in autistic children |
|---|---|---|
| Gestures | Points, shows, waves and nods, often to make up for missing words | Fewer gestures, especially pointing and showing to share interest |
| Pretend play | Feeds teddy, talks on a toy phone | Less pretend play; may prefer lining up or sorting toys |
| Responding to language | Usually responds to what is said at their level of understanding, even with few words | May respond less to what is said |
| Repeating speech | Copies words while learning them | May repeat whole phrases or lines (echolalia) well past age three |
| Beyond communication | Some routines and strong likes, as in most toddlers, but no wider pattern of differences | A wider pattern across several of these: repetitive movements, a strong need for routine, intense interests, or strong reactions to sounds, textures or light |
This table is a guide to what clinicians look at. It is not a checklist to score at home.
Why can it be hard to tell speech delay and autism apart?
Speech delay and autism can be hard to tell apart in the second year of life because the signs overlap. Researchers who follow babies over time describe separating the two at early ages as very difficult, even for specialists. Six things blur the picture:
- Late talkers can gesture less too. Toddlers with a language delay use fewer gestures than children who talk on time, though usually more than autistic toddlers.
- Eye contact is not a reliable test. In one comparison, late-talking toddlers were also weaker than typical talkers at using eye gaze and at back-and-forth interaction, so those two signs did not separate the groups.
- A child can have both. An autistic child can also have a language delay or a speech sound difficulty.
- Understanding can be delayed too. A child who understands less will respond less to what is said, whether or not they are autistic.
- Signs can appear later. Some autistic traits are not clear until a child is older, and some older children learn to mask them.
- Other causes exist. Hearing loss, including from repeated ear infections, can delay speech. A hearing test is part of working it out.
A single sign does not settle the question. A child who lines up cars, or who does not always answer to their name, is not autistic on that basis.
Can a toddler have a speech delay and not be autistic?
Yes. Most toddlers with a speech delay are not autistic. Late talking is common, and on its own it is not a sign of autism. Language delay is, however, one of the early reasons autistic children come to attention, which is why a speech pathologist or doctor will also look at gestures, play and interaction when a child is late to talk.
What should I do if I am not sure?
If you are not sure whether your child has a speech delay or is autistic, do not wait for it to become obvious. These steps apply either way:
- See your GP or child health nurse. Describe what you have noticed, with examples. Ask for a hearing test.
- See a speech pathologist. A speech pathologist can assess how your child understands, talks and communicates without words, and can start support straight away. You do not need a diagnosis first.
- Ask about an autism assessment if the concerns go beyond talking. Your GP can refer you to a paediatrician, child psychologist or child psychiatrist. There is no single test: assessment usually takes several sessions and may involve a team that includes a speech pathologist.
- Start support while you wait. Public assessments are usually free with a Medicare card, but waits are often long, sometimes more than a year. Speech therapy does not need to wait for that answer.
If your child loses words or skills they once had, see your GP promptly.
When to see a speech pathologist
See a speech pathologist if your child is not using about 50 words or joining two words by age two, is not trying to communicate with sounds, gestures or words by 12 months, or if you are worried at any age. You know your child better than any chart.
A speech pathologist assesses speech, language and communication and does not diagnose autism on their own. What they can do is tell you how your child’s communication is developing, share what they observe with your GP or paediatrician, and begin working with you.
Dr Lauren Crumlish (PhD) is a Certified Practising Speech Pathologist who works online with children and teenagers up to 18, including autistic children. Read about speech therapy for toddlers and late talkers and speech therapy for autistic children, or apply to work with Dr Lauren.
Sources
- The Royal Children’s Hospital Melbourne, Autism (signs in young children, who assesses, waiting times).
- Healthdirect Australia, Speech development in children (milestones, signs of delay, hearing, who to see).
- Paul, R., Chawarska, K. and Volkmar, F. (2008). Differentiating ASD from DLD in toddlers. Perspectives on Language Learning and Education.
- Rescorla, L. (2011). Late talkers: do good predictors of outcome exist? Developmental Disabilities Research Reviews.
- American Speech-Language-Hearing Association, Late language emergence (how common late talking is).
- Manwaring, S. and colleagues (2019). The gesture-language association over time in toddlers with and without language delays. Autism and Developmental Language Impairments.
- Iverson, J. and colleagues (2017). Early gesture and vocabulary development in infant siblings of children with autism spectrum disorder. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders.
- Henry, L. and colleagues (2018). Trajectories of cognitive development in toddlers with language delays. Research in Developmental Disabilities.
Topics
- Speech Delay
- Autism
- Late Talkers
- Early Years
- Kids